Signs You’re Being Overcharged

Hiring a property management company should make your life easier, not drain your profits. But what if you’re paying more than you should? Property management fees vary across Ontario, but there’s a fine line between fair pricing and being overcharged. If you own property in Hamilton or Niagara, here’s how to spot when you’re paying too much—and what to do about it.

What Are Standard Property Management Fees in Ontario?

Most property management companies in Ontario charge between 8% to 12% of the monthly rental income. Some companies may offer flat fees, but percentage-based pricing is more common.

However, factors like property type, location, and included services can affect the cost. For example:
✅ A multi-unit apartment complex might have different pricing than a single-family home.
✅ Some companies include tenant placement in their monthly fee, while others charge separately.

If you’re seeing numbers far above this range—or mysterious extra charges—it’s time to investigate.

Common Signs of Overcharging

🚩 Excessive Monthly Fees
If you’re paying more than 12% of your rent and you’re not getting premium services (like 24/7 emergency support or enhanced marketing), your fees might be inflated.

🚩 Hidden Fees & Unexpected Charges
Did your management company suddenly introduce an “admin fee” or a “maintenance coordination charge” that wasn’t in your contract? Sneaky add-ons are a red flag.

🚩 Overpriced Repairs & Maintenance
Some companies charge a markup on maintenance work—meaning you’re paying more than necessary for repairs. If you notice inconsistent or excessively high invoices, ask for a breakdown. Pro tip: Compare the rates with local contractors to see if you’re getting fair pricing.

🚩 High Leasing or Renewal Fees
Tenant placement usually costs between 50% to 100% of one month’s rent. But if your company is charging a full month’s rent or more—or asking for an unnecessary renewal fee—it’s worth questioning.

🚩 Paying for Services You Don’t Need
Are you being charged for marketing services when your unit is already occupied? Or paying for inspections that never happen? These are signs your property manager might be nickel-and-diming you.

How to Protect Yourself from Overcharging

🔎 Compare Companies
Before signing with a management company, get multiple quotes and compare services. Don’t just go with the first company you find!

📜 Read the Fine Print
Make sure your contract clearly outlines all fees—including leasing fees, maintenance costs, and administrative charges. If a company refuses to provide this transparency, walk away.

💡 Audit Your Invoices
Regularly review your financial statements. If something looks off, ask for an itemized breakdown of charges. A good property manager won’t hesitate to provide one.

🗣 Ask Other Property Owners
Word of mouth is powerful! Connect with other landlords in Hamilton or Niagara to compare costs and experiences.

Final Thoughts: Are You Paying Too Much?

A good property management company is worth every dollar—but not if you’re being overcharged. If your fees seem excessive, start asking questions. Reviewing your contract, comparing industry rates, and staying informed will help protect your investment.

💡 Want more insider property management tips? Subscribe to our newsletter and stay ahead of the game! 🏡📩